Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
House Salad
Tuscan Wrap
Sweet Chili Pizza
Baked Ziti Pizza
About
Cold Spring Pizza
Welcome to Cold Spring Pizza, a charming gem nestled in the heart of Cold Spring, NY, at 120 Main Street. This pizzeria offers an inviting atmosphere reminiscent of a classic 90s diner, where the love for pizza shines through every delicious slice. With a phone number of +1 845-265-9512, you can easily reach out to place your order or learn more about their offerings.
Cold Spring Pizza takes pride in its diverse menu, showcasing an array of options that cater to all pizza lovers. Choices range from their delightful Sicilian Pizza to a 10-inch Gluten-Free Pizza. If you're looking for something special, their gourmet selections include the Margherita Pizza topped with fresh mozzarella, marinara, and basil for just $25. The Chicken Parm Pizza and BBQ Chicken Pizza promise a savory experience, both available for $25. Not to be missed is their Eggplant Rollatini priced at $18, blending robust flavors with a comforting touch.
Customer feedback highlights the irresistible charm of Cold Spring Pizza. One patron, Crismeldy Segura, raved about the mouthwatering Margherita pie, praising its sauce that was "to die for." She noted the nostalgic vibe of the place and exceptional service, which enhances the experience of sharing fresh pizza with loved ones. Another reviewer, Pau Aliagas, described it as a lovely spot packed with local flavor, perfect for those exploring the hidden treasures on the route to NYC.
The reviews speak of a passionate approach to pizza-making, with satisfying flavors such as the thick mozzarella delight featured in their vodka slice. Pair that with double chocolate cookies warmed to perfection, and you have a winning combination. Michael even emphasized the visual appeal of the slices, perfectly crafted like art, and the reasonable prices make it an excellent value.
So, if you find yourself in Cold Spring, pop in to Cold Spring Pizza for a savory slice or two. Whether it's a quiet lunch at an outdoor table or a lively family dinner, this pizzeria captures the essence of comfort food in a delightful setting. Experience the flavors and feel the community vibe for yourself at this local treasure.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I stopped by this pizzeria on my visit to Cold Spring just this morning with my aunt and mom. We had a whole margarita pie and it was delicious!!!! The sauce on the pizza was to die for. The vibe inside is very old school, almost like it came out of a 90s movie from a small town. The service was great as well! My mom and aunt loved the pizza, and we even ended up bringing the extra slices to my dad and brother who both said it was excellent!! I definitely recommend them!! ”
“ In a hidden route to NYC, this little village is a small treasure. And in the middle of its Main St you can find a nice pizza shop. Good food, kind attention and full of local people. Nice place to get something to eat. ”
“ Stopped in after a late lunch at the Cold Spring Depot. Incredible vodka slice. Loads of thick mozzarella and an exceptional sauce with the perfect sweetness. They have double chocolate cookies that are warmed up in the oven too and were just as good as the pizza. Really good stuff at this place. Well worth a visit if in the area. ”
“ Good pizza! would appreciate if they put the prices on the menu ”
“ Slices look like a painting. Bae always gets a beef patty. Sat at the outside table. Everything was delicious and very filling. Price was reasonable. Took half of the extra cheese slice to go for later. Great place fuel up before a nearby Washburn trail hike. ”
“ CSP is my go-to pizzeria (even better cuz it’s family owned). The chicken bacon ranch pizza, the margarita pizza, the vodka pizza...just a few of my favorites the pinwheels always hit the spot. Not to mention the chicken Caesar wrap...perfection. Highly recommend this place! ”
“ 5 stars all around! Just want to say thank you to the cashier for being patient with me. Honestly i was flabbergasted by the total price. Everything came out to less than 20, literally, with 2 drinks and all. I saw this place feautured on tiktok! Dragged bae here for a day out in cold spring. Came by for some grubs before a hike. Everything tasted so clean and was very fulfilling. Thank you for a great time. ”
“ After another massive hike I was desperate for a cold beer and some hearty Italian food. To my surprise they stocked a good selection of beers as well as fizzy drinks. Their prices are decent and their portions are huge! I believe they are also connected to the ice cream shop next door. We’ll be back! ”